Skip to content
Ronkonkoma, NYCall 866-997-8544
Affinity Collectibles
Menu

Policies

Buyback Policy

Selling coins to us, including coins you bought here.

Last updated November 11, 2026. Affinitycollectables Inc DBA Affinity Collectibles.

Our commitment

We buy coins every day, and we'll always make an offer on coins you bought from us. We aren't obliged to buy any item back, and any offer is made at the market price on the day of the offer. Your dealer will explain how the offer was worked out: metal value, grade, and what similar coins have recently sold for.

How to sell to us

  1. Call your dealer at 866-997-8544, or start online at our coin-buying website SellMyCoinsNow, which handles collections, estates and bullion.
  2. Bring the coins to our Ronkonkoma shop, or ship them to us. For shipped collections we provide a prepaid, insured label.
  3. We inspect them and confirm the offer. You can accept it or decline it. If you decline, we send your coins back fully insured, at no cost to you, within 5 business days.
  4. Once you accept, you sign a bill of sale and we pay you by check or bank wire, usually within 5 business days.

What we need from you

  • A valid government-issued photo ID. Federal and New York rules require us to identify the people we buy from.
  • Your taxpayer ID when federal reporting rules require it.
  • Confirmation that the coins are yours to sell.

Consignment

For some coins, selling on consignment can bring a better result than an outright offer. Your dealer will explain the terms and fee in writing before we take anything on consignment.

See also our Terms of Sale & Use.

Questions

Call 866-997-8544 (Mon–Fri 8:30 am – 6:00 pm ET), email info@affinitycollectibles.com, or write to Affinitycollectables Inc DBA Affinity Collectibles, 2805 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Ste 17, Ronkonkoma, NY 11779.